How do you create a data-driven culture in your marketing team?

Becoming a data-driven organisation doesn’t just rely on the right technology, structure and processes. The human element is essential, and without the right skills, qualities and roles, any effort to be successful at data-driven marketing is destined to struggle.

And the kinds of skills that support a data-driven philosophy are rich and varied.

This is very true.  The "art" and "science" that requires actionable data lean more to the art side in most marketing departments.  The biggest change is to respect what data can bring to the equation.  Many marketers don't respect data, they respect their gut and soft metrics like awareness.  While data doesn't solve all problems, it helps inform direction.  It helps decide what is happening with the customers you are trying to target, plus the ones that you aren't targeting and whether you should.  

“The data-driven marketing team is knowledgeable enough to converse freely with technical and statistical resources while staying laser-focused on getting the right message to the right person at the right time. But the most important quality needed in a modern marketing team is curiosity. Without that, I may as well outsource all of my data related work to a third party. Curiosity stimulates creativity and conversation, and aids decision-making.” 

I like the statement of staying laser-focused on getting the right message to the right customer at the right time.  Too many times teams lose their focus and start drifting on to answers that are either easy or different from the most relevant topics.  Understanding what data is saying is more valuable than having the person who can put the report together.  Money is made by providing the insight to the data, that is what I look for in my team.  But don't forget to have the guy that can put all the data together.

Quintero adds: “Building a data-driven culture is not an overnight process. It takes time. To me, a data-driven culture means building a safe environment where experimentation is encouraged and mistakes are tolerated. It’s less about having all the right tools in place – although that’s a critical part of the process – and definitely more about cultivating excitement around discovery and objectivity. Being data-driven is exciting and people should be encouraged to enjoy the process as much as making things happen.”

Changing a culture is a journey.  Teaching the team about why decisions are made from looking at the data and what the thought process for coming to the conclusions is critical in building the data culture.  No matter how smart a person is, if they don't understand the thought processes of decisions they will never be able to take leaps with the data.  If they understand what to look for in data, they beginning asking the right questions and delivering recommendations along with their questions.

Data is the First Step to Marketing Automation

I have implemented many marketing automation solutions over the past decade and one of the perplexing findings is how organizations put the cart before the horse when they are installing their solutions.  I like to say marketing automation solutions are "dumb".  Not the kind of dumb as in "this is stupid, why are we implementing these solutions, why not do something else".  They are "dumb" in the essence of they need help from something else to be successful.  They cannot work on their own.

Marketing automation tools are a slave to the underlying data.  All marketing automation tools do is query data and create metadata that is used to create content and messaging for your customers.  Now I am minimizing the importance of the marketing automation tools in that sentence, but from a high level, it works.  

Since the underlying data is what drives the marketing automation tool, that data is the first step in implementing the tool.  Without the proper data, your implantation will fail.  Getting the data into the proper format for consumption from the automation tool is the most important step of marketing automation.  

Understand the problems to be solved

Write out all the different types of campaigns or communications to be run with the automation tool.  This step is vital to understand if there is a gap in your data collection strategy.  Also, this identifies if the data is structured properly to even run these types of campaigns.  This step comes before buying a marketing automation tool.

For example, I want to send a reminder email to all customers who bought a television that specific cables will enhance the performance of their new purchase by 50%.  For this, the data will have to be structured to understand which customer bought a television set, along with cables because you don't want to sound like you don't know your customers, within X amount of time, their email, mailing or app device ID, and the channel they prefer to be communicated with.  Now the data team can make sure they have the proper structure for just this one use case. If the data can't be structured accordingly, then the marketing automation tool will not be able to deliver this campaign.

Define success for the campaigns

This can be a simple sentence in each case.  What this determines is how the analysis of the campaigns performance will be achieved.  Analysis is also part of the marketing automation tool implantation, because I guarantee you that the executives will want to know the impact of this large investment, so the data needs to be prepared to answer these questions.

For example, I want to see the redemption rate and revenue generated, along with the expenses for delivering and cost of goods for the customers who returned to the store and purchased upgraded cables for their televisions.  For this the data will have to meld together the ID for the offer, in this case the cable, along with the purchase item along with the expense data from the marketing automation tool and the sales system.  These tasks aren't easy, but they will pay dividends if this legwork is done upfront.  There is nothing worse than flying blind with your marketing automation..  

 The expectations for campaign execution times

This is one that almost always gets missed.  I have heard of campaigns that run almost all day because the data is not organized in a fashion that is not optimized for the marketers.  That kind of performance may be acceptable if the campaigns are run once a month, but for most businesses that is not the speed of digital marketing.  

For example, I want to be able to run the campaign for the television purchasers every day.  This includes time to run the automation, send out proofs for the collateral and have the deliveries out to the customer by 10AM.  This allows the data team to be able to optimize the data structures to make sure the data can be pulled fast and efficiently for all your automation campaigns.  

This by no means is an exhaustive list, but it is a start to having a successful marketing automation implementation.  No matter how many bells and whistles the marketing automation tools have, if the data does not support the wants and needs of the marketer, it doesn't matter because the tool is "dumb".  It needs the data to perform magic.     

Building credibility for your analytics team—and why it matters

If you work with data regularly, chances are you trust it. You know how it's collected and stored. You know the caveats and the roadblocks you face when analyzing it. But, when you bring your findings to those further removed, you're asking them to take a leap of faith and trust in data they may know very little about.

Multiple times in my career I had to come into organizations and take teams that were not trusted in the organization and help build them into the trusted source of data accuracy and insights.  This journey is never easy.  It takes patience and requires a lot of persistence to change an organizations perception of the department.  But these points are good advice on a roadmap to do this.

Start Small

When trying to get people to believe in your team, it can be tempting to chase the biggest problems first. These problems often take a long time to answer, and can take several tries to get right. It's often better to first establish trust by picking early projects that you know you can win, and win quickly.Try starting with basic arithmetic to answer crucial business and product questions. For startups, some example questions might be:

• What are the most engaging features of your product?

• What is the company's core demographic? What do they like about the product?

Often, people don’t judge the answers to these questions on technical rigor, they judge them on business impact. Starting small can open doors to the big questions that you may have wanted to start with; if you've earned credibility along the way, you'll have more time, flexibility—and maybe resources—to tackle them.

I always find it helpful to start answering questions that are not currently being answered.  As Derek Steer points out in the article, don't start by trying to solve the worlds problem.  If your team tries to tackle tough problems, there will be a much more critical eye on the work and the data produce.  Allow your team to get some wins under its belt.  Remember, this is a journey, not a sprint.  Trust comes with wins, not home runs.

Know your audience

Keep your audience in mind as you begin to craft the story from your data. Add in the appropriate amount of detail your audience needs to focus on decisions rather than methods. What context might they need? Spending a little time thinking about what your audience cares about most also helps you anticipate possible questions and prepare answers in advance. Few things can help establish credibility faster than fielding a question during a presentation and immediately flipping to a slide that answers it.

This point is critical to garner trust.  When presenting data, make sure there is a story that is being told along with the data.  Guide the audience to the answers that you have found, don't let them have to figure it our themselves.  Be sure to explain to the audience what they are seeing and why it matters.  Make it simple, quick and insightful.

Don’t be a House

House, a brilliant albeit fictional doctor, routinely diagnosed rare diseases but had abysmal bedside manner. The thing was, House didn’t have to win his patients over—they were so desperate to survive that they would listen to his every word.

It's subtle, but consider your findings a conversation starter. Understand that the non-analysts have valid points too: they have experiences you don't have and they likely know something you don't. These discussions aren't about winning an argument, but making the right decision for the business.

Never use data for evil.  This is fairly common in Finance departments, but it is important not to attack decisions, but rather try to initiate conversations to come to the best business decision.  Once there is a tone of implication in the analysis, your team will lose the trust of the department that you are creating the analysis for.  Those departments made decisions that didn't have data to drive their decisions, so treat them as a partner, not someone that needs help.

Be Transparent

Analytics can feel like a black box to many people—making that leap of faith appear even larger. By showing even just the basics of your process, you can help others believe in it. To increase transparency try:

• Making your work simple and understandable. Monica Rogatti would urge you to try division before doing anything harder. As your audience becomes more comfortable, up the game to simple regression models—it's not usually difficult for folks to understand the direction and magnitude of coefficients.

• Finding simple ways to convey advanced concepts. For example,confidence intervals and p-values can be confusing for many people, but charts with error bars make these concepts easy to understand.

• Using stories. If you're presenting information about feature usage, or events with technical backend names, paint a picture of how a user would see these features, or put events in plain-English names.

Numbers are difficult to interpret at times, taking the complex and being able to tell a story with it is an art.  Most analysts are great at finding data and creating insights if they have domain knowledge, however they can be terrible at communicating their findings.  Always have available the methodology for coming up with the answers, even if you believe it is a waste of time.  The haters in the organization will demand this, but it also humanizes the process for the non-analytical audience members that you want on your side.  

The most important part of the journey is to persevere.  The beginning of the journey is the hardest part.  I remember in my last position, the department I took over was the laughing stock of the organization.  It took them weeks to come up with an answer and no one believed in what they were saying because they were just being report monkeys, instead of providing any insights.  By the time we got going, we were the defacto data source for the organizations.  We created analysis for parts of the organization we didn't have anything to do with, but when the organization needed something done right, it came through our team.  That was because we had many wins along a journey.  

Turn Your Data Into Smart Data

Great insights from Scott Houchin regarding data.

To harness and convert data into stronger business strategies and overall profitability, approach data practices with a holistic integration of people, process and technology, following three key steps: collection, strategy and alignment.

A data strategy is the first step in becoming a data-driven organization.  Setting up the structure and expertise of the organization has to start before jumping into data strategies.  This can happen outside of the confines of IT.  The business leaders should own the data, as long as they have the expertise and knowledge to do so.  Try to set up procedures to be agile with your processes.  The longer it takes to implement changes in data, the less of a competitive advantage your organization has.  It will also be near impossible to become data-driven if there is a constant wait for data to be delivered to the end users.

Collection

Start with a clear understanding of project goals and requirements to guide the collection process. Establishing this helps ensure data collected is “smart” or meaningful. Collection shouldn’t narrowly focus on new data. Many organizations already have a goldmine of owned data that should be tapped. To make the most of historical data, scan legacy systems, such as social pages or purchase history, map findings back to strict uniform terminology, and fill in the gaps where data is missing across the organization.

Having a process for collecting new data and examining historical data up front ensures quick and accurate collection, minimizing time spent on governance practices and carving down unnecessary data sets.

There is a treasure trove of data already being collected in most organizations.  Ensure that this data is being properly collected and stored.  The goal is to ensure as many people can get to the data as possible, data democratization.  If data is stored and is hard to get to, takes complicated joins and there are no tools available to the organization to easily access the data, then more has to be done to reach these goals.

Strategy

Once data is collected, work with data-marketing specialists to analyze and align functional uses and marketing’s business goals. This requires a team of analysts and strategists who have both high levels of industry and domain expertise to identify sources, manage collection and road-map operations processes.

Teams of analysts can help organizations identify, collect and integrate data from sources and channels, like web traffic, Facebook, Salesforce, etc., into a proprietary database. Once established on a datamart, it can be integrated into current campaign tools through human labor. Having this data integrated into marketing tools gives brand-side marketers the insights to improve customer experiences, measure performance of digital assets, predict customer decision stages, etc.

Data should not be financial focused, it should be customer focused for the greatest impact on ROI.  Marketers have to own their data.  Hiring analysts and data domain expertise is imperative for success.  If ownership lies outside of the marketing resources, there is a much higher likelihood of failure.  Remember, CMO's and CIO's don't speak the same language.  

Alignment

Another example can be demonstrated with IT and marketing. Marketers spend more on technology than some IT departments now, but need alignment to ensure data is stored, platforms are integrated and in-house technical support is available. Alignment between these two departments appeases both marketer’s need for autonomy and IT’s domain over platforms, allowing for the integration of datamarts into other units’ datasets from the onset.

IT is still very critical for success with this strategy.  Just because IT does not own the data, doesn't mean they aren't extremely important.  IT needs to ensure the network is working, data is flowing and collection tools are working.  They also need to be support for when things break and they should control the access to the systems.  Make sure IT understands the goals and agree on the toolsets being chosen, so they can support them.  

Are CMOs wasting money on faulty marketing analytics?

Manji Matharu writes:

CMOs are now at a crossroads between data quality and data results. It’s no longer enough to dabble in analytics and come out with the richness required for informed decision-making. The business needs integrated systems across IT infrastructure, and marketers — not IT pros — must champion the call for improved data controls and governance as their cause.

Data quality is the first step in all marketing processes.  Ensuring this is boring and hard, but it is a necessity.  This is the first step when I come into an organization, determine the quality of the data and work to fix that.  Once there is a trusted version of the truth, marketing analytics come to life.